Re: UV-5R SOTA in high levels of RF
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I have two ft-60 and two UV-5r radios. When starting in radio the china radios did not exist but bang for the buck was ft-60 with diamond 77 antenna. Maybe $200 investment and made home brew antenna for sat work. Easy to field program, squelch dial, one button reverse, easy power changes. After I bought UV-5r just because I could program to transmit out of armature freq. for business at work. I tested after much satellite work with the FT-60 vs the UV-5r. Needless to say the new operator and or other operator would soon grow frustrated.
With that I would say with improved antenna the UV is ok radio yet frustrating for field programming or more complicated use for new operator.
Question is how many UV does one buy until “good” one is found of throw in the money for filters, antenna and other things in hopes it might work. Or just buy quality radio that most likely will work out of the box and even better with simple antenna improvement?
I consider the UV radios a disposable but when going into the woods they stay home and the FT-60 is in the pack.
My two cents.
From: firstname.lastname@example.org [mailto:email@example.com] On Behalf Of Paul Butzi (W7PFB) via groups.io
Sent: Saturday, February 19, 2022 7:39 AM
Subject: Re: [SnoVARC] UV-5R SOTA in high levels of RF
My cousin Curt K7ZOO is pretty active with SOTA in Arizona (among his other interesting projects is a plan to do summit to summit SOTA using heliographs).
His experience is that he is often able to hear stations on his Yaesu handheld that cannot be heard on SOTA partner's Baofeng UV-5r. This is on summits that are in the middle of nowhere, so there are no other transmitters within miles.
Caveat: while it’s likely true that all FT-60’s perform alike, or that all Kenwood TH-F6a’s perform alike, it is most definitely not the case that all Baofeng UV-5r’s will perform alike, because of variations over time in which compromises are made for one particular batch of UV-5R radios.
An interesting article on building a bandpass filter is at https://www.arrl.org/files/file/Technology/Intermod/No_Tune_Filter.pdf
Note that both the filter described in the article and the SOTABEAMS filter have 3db of insertion loss, meaning that unless you get the filter out of your antenna feed when you transmit, the filter is eating half of the power and your 5 watt radio is effectively a 2.5W radio.
All very interesting stuff!